Short answer: Count the cartons against the packing list, pull a random sample sized by AQL (for a 5,000-piece lot at General Inspection Level II that is 200 boxes), check each against the approved sample for artwork, colour, size, construction and function, and accept or reject the lot on the defect counts you agreed before production.

Before the goods arrive

  • Keep the approved pre-production sample and the signed-off artwork; they are the reference, not memory or a screen. See the pre-production sample checklist.
  • Agree in writing what counts as critical, major and minor, the AQL for each, and what happens to a lot that fails.
  • Have the drawing with interior and exterior dimensions; the measuring guide explains which is which.

Step 1: Count and check the cartons

Match carton count, carton marks and quantity per carton to the packing list. Photograph any crushed or wet carton before opening it; transit damage is a claim against the carrier or forwarder, not a production defect. For crush and scuff patterns see preventing packaging damage.

Step 2: Pull a random sample by AQL

AQL sampling (ISO 2859-1, or its US twin ANSI/ASQ Z1.4) sets how many boxes to check and how many defects are allowed. General Inspection Level II is the usual level for a visual check. Read the sample size and accept/reject numbers for your lot size from the standard's tables; the row below is one worked example.

Lot sizeLevel II code / sampleMajor defects, AQL 2.5Minor defects, AQL 4.0
3,201–10,000 pcs (e.g. 5,000)L / 200 boxesaccept if 10 or feweraccept if 14 or fewer

Source for this row: QualityInspection.org, AQL 2.5 samples and inspection levels in ISO 2859-1. Many buyers allow zero critical defects. Pull boxes from different cartons, not the top layer of one.

Step 3: Check each sampled box

CheckHowTypical class
Artwork and textCompare logo, copy, barcode and spelling with the approved artworkCritical if wrong or unreadable
ColourSide by side with the approved sample under the same lightMajor if outside the agreed limit; see colour matching
DimensionsInterior and exterior with a rigid ruler or caliper against the drawing toleranceMajor if the product does not fit
ConstructionWrap adhesion, corners, lid fit, sleeve tensionMajor if it peels or will not close
FunctionMagnet closes, drawer slides, insert holds the productMajor if it fails
FinishFoil, embossing, scuffs and glue marks at arm's lengthMinor if cosmetic only

Step 4: Record and decide

Log each defect with a photo, box number and carton number, then total them by class. If majors or minors exceed the accept number, the lot fails; act on what you agreed before production (sorting, rework or replacement) and send the supplier the log, not just a summary. Keep the sample boxes until the matter is closed.

Ordering with us: rigid and magnetic boxes start at 100 pcs per size. Orders below 500 pcs carry a noticeably higher unit price, so we recommend 500 pcs or more. Every order goes through a pre-production sample (3–5 days) before production (12–15 days).

Formats to Inspect Against a Golden Sample

Ready to price one of these? Send a quote request — the reply includes a free 3D mockup.

Frequently Asked Questions

What AQL should I use for custom gift boxes?
A common choice is AQL 2.5 for major defects and 4.0 for minor defects at General Inspection Level II, with zero critical defects. Agree it with the supplier before production.
How many boxes should I inspect from 5,000 pcs?
At General Inspection Level II a 5,000-piece lot falls in the 3,201 to 10,000 band, code letter L, sample size 200. At AQL 2.5 the lot passes with 10 or fewer major defects; at AQL 4.0, 14 or fewer minor defects.
Is transit damage a production defect?
No. Crushed or wet cartons from shipping are a claim against the carrier or forwarder. Photograph them before opening and keep them separate from the production defect count.
What is the reference for colour and finish?
The approved pre-production sample, checked side by side under the same light, not the screen artwork.

LuxoPack is a custom rigid box factory in Shenzhen. Formats: magnetic gift boxes, rigid gift boxes, all products. Related reading: Gift Box Size Guide, How to Measure a Box, Dimensional Weight Calculator, MOQ Guide.